They mistakenly compare Israel to the British. When in fact these were Arabs who sided with the British. The British blocked Jewish immigration. The British sided with the Arabs. The British appointed the leader of Trans-Jordan army - Glubb. And the Jews were also fighting against the British after the WWII. Education matters, but only when it's not a fake propaganda to brainwash your children.
This is an outstanding piece. I applaud your courage in publicly defending Israel. Unfortunately, freedom of speech seems to only travel in one direction in Ireland today and truth has become the casualty. There are probably many who agree with you but consider the social cost of expressing that as too high a price to pay. I witnessed a pro Palestinian (really pro Hamas) march in Cork last year that was frightening.
As an Irish Jew I despair at the hysteria that appears to have overcome my fellow citizens. I see in today’s paper that a group within the GAA wants to end Alllianz 32 year sponsorship of Gaelic games for no other reason than that company has done business in Israel. The madness seems to have no end.
Keep up the good work. As a fellow Limerickman I’ll still come back for the hurling, Luimneach abu!
This is a gross distortion. Some ex-RIC joined the Palestine Police after the disbandment of the RIC which was as far back as 1922 - about 700 joined the Palestine Gendarmerie - which in itself was disbanded in 1926 - and then perhaps no more than 200 remained in the 2 reconstituted forces that policed Transjordan and Palestine - some of which indeed remained throughout the Arab Revolt. They were certainly not "deployed....to brutalize the Palestinian Arab population" and indeed a large majority of the Palestinian police members after 1926, where in fact Muslim Palestinians. The deeply violent massacre and expulsion of the Jews of Hebron in the 1929 'riots' (a mixture of indigenous & newly settled Jews were targeted) and the inaction of the Palestinian police in stopping it (in some cases, the police took part), led to a reconstitution of the police forces thereafter. The Arab Revolt - and more violent anti-Arab (and anti Jewish) police actions only escalated after 1936. B &T involvement would have been marginal.
and FWIW...the self-styled 'anti-imperialist' Irgun split from regular Jewish resistance forces in attacking British targets. In doing this, they very publicly copied (and admired) IRA tactics to attack British military targets until 1948. These escalated during and after ww2 and indeed the most high profile attacks (inc. the assassination of the staunch Unionist Lord Moyne / bombing of British Army HQ by Irgun irregulars).
Overall, it's fair to say that the British military echelons - and rank & file - were split in their opinions of the Jews & Arabs. British did actively supply the Jordanian and Egyptian states in waiting with training and weaponry - and were far less inclined to do so regarding Jewish nationalist aspirations.
Not even mentioning that the British didn’t act to protect the Jews when they were killed by Arabs in Hebron, and the fact of White Paper invented literally to satisfy the Arabs (and they were satisfied.)
Indeed, taking a step back, the Palestinian police forces first and foremost served the British administration of the League of Nations Mandate - not a permanent British colonial mandate. Any ex-RIC participation would have been largely motivated by career considerations, rather than some form of sadistic ideology, let alone 'anti-Arab' considerations, which of course would have been counterintuitive to the prevailing anti-Ottoman / pro-British political winds that relied on Arab nationalist support. Indeed, modern Arab nationalism was arguably fostered by British political and colonial powers to counter Ottoman, Russian and other imperial forces - even French aspirations. The issue of Jewish national independence obviously played an adjacent role in the post WW1 landscape.
Comments like JayBug's simply reflect an 'anti-British / anti-imperialist' prism of the conflict that somehow needs to always tie into the Irish (nationalist) experience and appoint binary adversaries and roles. No nuance and certainly no consideration for the on the ground complexities and sensibilities play a role therein - so yes, it is informed by a sense of bigotry and anti-Jewish sentiment - manifesting as an unwillingness to ascribe national value to the Jewish indigenous experience (even if a minority in a minor Ottoman outpost) and the moral and legal legitimacy of first & second aliyah Jewish settlement - which did not displace Arab populations or rights.
An explicit policy to create a “national home for the Jewish people” is "siding with the Arabs"? The Arabs certainly didn't feel that way in 1947, and nor does anyone who is familiar with the history of the region, and certainly not Israeli historian's such as Benny Morris.
He's referring to the White Paper of 1939, conceived by the British to restrict Jewish national aspirations (and immigration) and to facilitate a bi-national state in which Jews would be a minority (and all that that entailed for their future rights - see Iraq, Egypt et al), rather than 2 separate states. It was overwhelmingly skewed to Arab national interests. It also represented a significant official shift away from the Balfour declaration. It found favour with mainstream Arab movements, yes.
Yes correct. This was also done concurrently with the Holocaust, essentially creating a reality in which the Jews had absolutely no place in the world to find refuge from Nazism on the scale that was needed to save European Jewry.
Thank you for confronting Pappé. The pushback against this fraudster is far too absent. His "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" is a work of stunning academic malpractice... fake footnotes, 1948 Arab-invasion denial, antisemitic terminology ("cabal"), and worse. For those who don't know what to think, this video is a must-see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1_dc2wuteg
An Israeli acquaintance of mine told me many years ago that Pappe' was known in Israel as a complete charlatan, even amongst radical Israelis. The fact that he has become the spokesperson for European 'Anti Zionists" is a complete insult to the Israeli educational and political body. It would be the equivalent of selecting Karl Marx as the spokesperson for German society today. Yes Marx was German, but he also wanted to destroy Germany.
Are you able to provide a detailed list of every citation that you state is fake? I've read the book, and to be honest it's historiography is broadly centred along the same lines as that put forward by the other New Historians. The difference is the moral axiom that he takes in setting out to show that the creation of Israel was a strategic act of ethnic cleansing. I don't think the evidence gets us to that, but no one can deny that significant atrocities were committed which in turn drove depopulation of Arab settlements.
I recommend watching the video. It identifies endnotes that have no relevance to the text but are merely decorative.
Also, many of Pappé's endnotes simply state a volume/page number - no content - from a Hebrew-language resource that is unavailable to the public. These are the "newly declassified documents" on which his very thesis of ethnic cleansing depends. His thesis is that the five-country Arab invasion of day-old Israel was not the key point in 1948 but rather a minor, irrelevant, even doubtful event. Per Pappé, the true cause of anything that went wrong for Palestinians was malevolent backroom plotting by a Jewish cabal led by Ben-Gurion.
It's interesting, given how critical such documentation is to this new (and frankly, trope-laden thesis) that readers are fully satisfied with Pappé's opaque documentation style.
So I would like a detailed list of Pappé's Hebrew resource citations and their content. Also: per AI calculations, a disproportionately large number of Pappé's scholarly citations in "Ethnic Cleansing" are from his own works (see updated video link beneath recommended video).
You state , "no one can deny that significant atrocities were committed which in turn drove depopulation of Arab settlements," this is false. That there were "significant atrocities" and that alleged atrocities are what drove off Palestinians are by no means assertions accepted by all, including by all Arab scholars and witnesses. And, even if so, "consensus equals truth" is a reasoning fallacy.
Lastly, Jews are tired of playing defense against every fantastical demonization, even ones couched as "scholarship." Time for the accusers to provide a detailed explanation of why they killed their grandmother.
This is the same tactic Holocaust deniers are using. I often find myself going to the "go fuck yourself" response when I start getting asked to disprove lies.
"Just last week, while arguing that Ireland was not antisemitic, prominent radio host Pat Kenny put it to Dominic Green (a writer for ‘the Telegraph’ among other publications) that “Netanyahu orders the IDF to go into Gaza and kill babies”."
During the 2008-2009 academic year, I completed my Master's of Science (Development Studies) at UCD. The department head would not call Israel, Israel, but instead consistently, confidently, and arrogantly referred to it as Palestine. Again, this was in 2008-2009! The anti-semitism running through the Irish universities has been institutionalized for some time. As a Jew, I did not say anything because I was 23 years old at the time. I was confused and felt ashamed to be Jewish, as everyone else in the room just acted like this was normal.
Thoroughly good and very insightful. As a Spaniard takinh the same stance, though less public, I can testify to how hard it is to see old friends turn on you simply for defending life while they pretend to hold the moral wand by defending terrorists. As a teacher, I am thoroughly ashamed of the profession, steadily working for the spread of Anti-Semitism, and as for my friends in acad6, they have preferred to continue with their utterly fake stance and have severed ties with me after the Bondi attacks. I kept on warning a highly positioned friend of many years at a University in Melbourne, that silence was the same as acquiescence but the attack did not change their set in stone mind.
Dietrich Bon Hoeffer said "Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless.Not to speak is to speak.Not to act is to act." He paid the ultimate price for opposing Nazism in Germany
I agree. The longer the silence, the deeper the wound. Not because I will miss what I thought they were, as friends were not, but because of what it means where it really matters: every day life for Jewish people every where, every day.
I saw this car crash starting to happen, which is why I left Ireland twenty years ago. It is mainly the doing of the Ireland Palestine Solidarity Campaign, although they were obviously pushing at an open door.
It seems to me that what you are describing is not a disagreement over policy but a collision with a closed moral economy.
Israel creates a particular problem for Irish political culture because it combines elements that Ireland’s moral self-image refuses to digest: a people with a genuine history of persecution who achieved sovereignty, exercise military power, and refuse to dissolve themselves to preserve moral innocence. Israel does not fit the role Ireland has assigned to “the victim.”
Irish nationalism is morally organised around resistance. The moment resistance succeeds, violence has to be re-mythologised or disowned. This is why IRA violence is frozen in a symbolic role: retroactively moralised, narrativised as tragic necessity, detached from its victims, and folded into national identity.
Israel, by contrast, exercises force as a sovereign state in real time, with consequences, trade-offs, and responsibility. There is no symbolic purification available. That difference strikes me as hugely significant.
The deeper structure is a binary Ireland depends on: victimhood is moral; power is immoral. Israel violates that binary by being a victim with power. The response is therefore not argument but inversion (Israel as uniquely evil), projection (genocide language), obsession (disproportionate focus), and moral certainty that no debate is required.
That is why what you describe sounds hysterical rather than argumentative. It is the sound of moral language failing to bind reality. Most people lose the ability to hear that after prolonged exposure. You haven’t yet, and that is precisely why the reaction still feels so stark.
You say Israel represents light and goodness. This doesn't fit with the vast destruction in Gaza. Not 'only' have Israel killed over 70,000 people in Gaza, they are allowing the violence, death and despair to spead into the West Bank where it seems Israelis can beat up or kill local people with impunity.
These are not the actions of a good or moral country. Not are they likely to build long term peace.
Allies killed more than 6 million Germans because in that war Allies represented light and goodness.
Israeli extremists end up in Israeli prisons which is the exact opposite of paying terrorists to slay Jews, as practiced by PA. Recently Israel made 276 arrests and 154 indictments.
Of course, you might be referring to Israel’s action against Hamas, Islamic Jihad, ISIS and other Jew-murdering genocidal terrorist entities based in the West Bank. That is indeed done “with impunity”. IDF had an absolute moral obligation to defend Israeli citizens. October 7th failure taught them a valuable lesson.
Hamas charter is explicitly genocidal. Their ideology is from the Muslim Brotherhood. Islam has a long and bloody history of imperialistic conquest, colonialism, enslavement of non-Muslims, and oppression. Radical Muslims fully embrace that as good and see jihad as their duty. The “ Hamas entity” (see how that phrase can go both ways?) isn’t an resistance group. They are vile, evil jihadists. If anything, Israel has gone too easy on them. Jihadists should be exterminated and given no quarter. They are a menace to humanity.
The genocide was on October 7th when Hamas deliberately targeted Israeli civilians - including children and babies. Targeting Palestinian terrosts (Hamas) is only a “genocide” to their supporters.
Read Andrew Fox, Jake Wallis Simons, Douglas Murray, Melanie Phillips, John Spencer, James Glancy, Bernard Henri-Levy, and more, who all have experience and knowledge on the ground. And read them for what they actually have to say, rather than under any kind of heading about them.
Gosh, what an exceptionally intelligent and well-argued riposte from someone who has clearly researched the situation very carefully and not yielded to any emotion.
As an evident “expert” in urban warfare, what precisely would you have done differently than the IDF, given Hamas’ extensive tunnel infrastructure and abuse of otherwise protected sites such as hospitals, university buildings, mosques and private residences.
Real experts, such as West Point’s John Spencer, and over a hundred top Western military officers who have gone to see and investigate for themselves, take a radically different position from your lounge chair pontificating. To them, there is much to learn from an army that has brought the civilian-combatant ratio to an historic low in unprecedentedly complex battlefield conditions.
As any impartial observer would conclude, the devastation wrought in Gaza is a direct consequence of the strategy Hamas adopted and the tactics it spent nearly 20 years putting in place - with, it seems, the complicity of certain U.N. entities.
So you may spare us your uninformed, performative moralizing. Regurgitating Hamas talking points no longer convince anyone but the most ideologically driven.
Israel needed to start building peace decades ago. Every major decision they've made in the last twenty or thirty years has made the long term situation worse. Israel hold all the power, and with that comes responsibility.
You do know that Israel is surrounded by nearly 400 million Arab Muslims across 22 Arab majority states - a fact that should put paid to the “settler-colonial” nonsense framing. Why is it for Israel to “start building peace” while you ascribe zero agency to any Arab country?
In fact, over the decades, it has been Israel, in cooperation with willing Arab counterparts, that has built peace through treaties with Egypt and Jordan and more recently the Abraham Accords which stands as a framework for greater regional integration.
Maybe you really mean only the Palestinians and not the Arab world at large. If so, you have, on the one hand, fallen for stale Soviet propaganda that reframed the Arab-Israeli conflict to an Israeli-Palestinian one and turned an Islamist supremacist narrative into a “national liberation” one. On the other, you conveniently ignore the multiple attempts by Israel at peace faced always with the rejectionist mentality of the Palestinians that sees not coexistence with Israel but its replacement by another Arab majority country in which minorities live at sufferance.
In Gaza, the Palestinians had an opportunity to show what type of state they could build and on October 7, the world found out. Either the PA or Hamas could have built something sustainable, instead Hamas ousted the PA and began cross-border attacks which led to both Israel and Egypt closing their respective borders. As we have now witnessed, that blockade of arms was anything but hermetic. But the bottom line is that the Palestinians chose their way forward
So, it would appear that you - like so many others - have things precisely backwards: it’s for the Palestinians to “start building peace”. Unless you are among the legion who imagine them to be without any agency (in the face of all evidence) and so fall back on both a “White savior” complex twinned with a racism of low expectations, that’s the only way forward. Having Israel continue to bargain against itself is no longer an option after October 7.
Until the Palestinians become serious about nation building and coexistence, their future will remain dim.
This is spot on. The Palestinians have started and lost numerous wars with Israel since 1949. The pattern in human history is that peoples who do that lose territory as a result. But western defenders of Palestines act as if they are some special case and shouldn’t be responsible for their actions. They aren’t.
Good or moral country? Ever ask yourself why, if Israel loves killing Palestinians, it doesn't kill the ones in its own prisons but instead sustains them well past their intel use? Why it gave ex-prisoner Sinwar life-saving cancer treatment so he could go on to implement Oct. 7? Or why the kibbutz victims had helped transport Gazans to hospitals and jobs and had peace magnets on their refrigerators? Ever ask yourself why Palestinian babies are featured in media day after day, ideally with genetic diseases passed off as starvation (later admitted - maybe - in fine print) but Russian baby casualties of Ukrainian militancy or any other war are not (do you seriously think such baby victims don't exist)? Ever ask yourself *anything* beyond The New York Times narrative? Your morality compass falls on the side that won't even protect is *own* people with bomb shelters, and hides militants and weapons under hospitals (fact)? And do you know how many of the "70,000" people killed in Gaza (Hamas's figure) were militants? Shouldn't you?
I have never said Hamas are/were anything but awful. Yes, they're worse than the IDF, but Israel has all the power and any civilised society should aim for a higher bar than just ‘not as bad as Hamas’.
70,000 dead in Gaza plus a thousand killed with impunity in the West Bank. Do you really accept that is the behaviour of a decent society?
*Decency* explained: Israel putting up with Hamas's rocket fire for years and years and only responding when they went full-barbaric. Also decent that although all war is horrible, casualties (whatever the true number is) would undoubtedly be higher if not for Israel's moral code of issuing warnings to civilians, doing targeted attacks, and having to deal with an enemy population that is martyr-minded and deliberately placed in harm's way. You know Hamas is worse than Israel, so it's Hamas you should be debating; and if you can't, you should weigh the reason equitably. Instead, it's always about "Jewish morality on trial," a 2000 year-old farce; as is the "all-powerful" business. Hamas was holding civilian hostages, it has the backing of nuke-loving Iran and cash-flush Qatar, not to mention Western love--that's a whole lot of power. This is my last comment. Good luck.
Israel killed about 170 Palestinians before Oct 7th 2023.
This is not normal behaviour for a developed country. But my main criticism of Israel is it's behaviour over the last 30 years. So many decisions have been taken that just made the tension worse, with no attempt to move towards a permanent peace.
Of course Hamas are worse, but they're not the dominant force in the region. Only Israel can choose the direction.
Hamas is now rewarding 50,00 widows of slain Hamas terrorists from the war. Then at least 8,000 died of natural causes. This is all public knowledge. Do the math.
How many of these people were Hamas, Islamic Jihad or other terrorists or “civilians” who also participated in the atrocities of 10/7 and beyond starting a war theyncouldnt win. Or are they all children under the age of 11 as international media parroting Hamas lies would have you believe? Obviously you have.
Jews can’t “settle” their homeland hon. “Palestinian” Arabs have Jordanian and Egyptian DNA - that’s where they come from. Gaza was part of Egypt and the “West Bank” was Transjordan. Palestinian Arabs have no indigenous rights to greater Israel. They were offered their own state in 1948 - and violently refused because Arab supremacy would never allow non-Muslim Jewish dhimmis and their diaspora brethren self-determination. Boo hoo they lost. That neither Egypt nor Jordan want them back speaks to their decades of fomenting violence (Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and Black September Jordan 1970-71).
Good and moral countries take action against genocidal entities that preach and carry out death and martyrdom against their citizens.
Not a single death would have occurred except for Oct 7. The PA pays lifelong stipends to Palestinians who murder Jews, thus incentivizing terror.
One side continually preaches hatred and "river to the sea," kills gays and has zero Jews.
The other side has 25% of its population Muslim/Arab/christian/Druze/Beduin/Bahai with full rights.
Bethlehem went from 80% Christian to under 10% after the PA started ruling it, yet within Israel proper, the Christian population grows, the only such phenomenon in the entire ME.
There is zero equivalence except in the mind of antisemites.
70,000? I thought it was 7 million. It took years to get an accurate casualty count in Iraq (as it does in all wars) so I’ll wait until the post-war analysis is done and not rely on propaganda from the Hamas Health Ministry.
Excellent piece. We live in a time of widespread delusion manifested by moral inversion. Vast numbers of people are (to use the phraseology of Solzhenitsyn) “living by lies”. I am not Jewish, but I am appalled by the lies being told about Israel and Jews in general. Equally disgusting is the praise being heaped on murderous Islamist groups and regimes. It takes a strong sense of self and morality to push back against this tide of hatred and bigotry. This young man is very brave and selfless. He deserves wider recognition and respect.
Do you have any answer to why Ireland has become so consumed by Jew hatred? The question applies to everywhere in the Western world.
My own answer is tentatively that it is a combination of leftists being downstream of Marxist antisemitism, Islamic antisemitism, the internationalist hatred of both towards the original and quintessential nation state arising out of covenant with the divine, and a demonic rage against God, truth and goodness.
When I was a child we learned that the IRA was trained by PLO. I think Sinn Féin propagates that Palestinians and Irish still have a similar struggle...
Ireland may not be intrinsically antisemitic, but it certainly comes across that way when its loudest voices adopt such maliciously false beliefs about Israel.
What is clear to any impartial observer is that the holdover antisemitism from the days of the supremacy of the Catholic Church in Ireland combined with a deformed Leftism unable to this day to separate from Soviet propaganda creates the fertile ground for antisemitism’s vulgar and crude expression - your serial commentary to this article being a case in point.
The only documented crime is your ongoing one against the English language and your intentional confusion between reality and what your ideology requires you to believe. Many readers will feel sorry for you and the delusions it spawned.
They mistakenly compare Israel to the British. When in fact these were Arabs who sided with the British. The British blocked Jewish immigration. The British sided with the Arabs. The British appointed the leader of Trans-Jordan army - Glubb. And the Jews were also fighting against the British after the WWII. Education matters, but only when it's not a fake propaganda to brainwash your children.
Jamie,
This is an outstanding piece. I applaud your courage in publicly defending Israel. Unfortunately, freedom of speech seems to only travel in one direction in Ireland today and truth has become the casualty. There are probably many who agree with you but consider the social cost of expressing that as too high a price to pay. I witnessed a pro Palestinian (really pro Hamas) march in Cork last year that was frightening.
As an Irish Jew I despair at the hysteria that appears to have overcome my fellow citizens. I see in today’s paper that a group within the GAA wants to end Alllianz 32 year sponsorship of Gaelic games for no other reason than that company has done business in Israel. The madness seems to have no end.
Keep up the good work. As a fellow Limerickman I’ll still come back for the hurling, Luimneach abu!
Why don’t the Jews leave? And American companies go with them?
That's clever. Speak to your conscience...and your economy.
Yep, pure and insane projection.
The British literally deployed the Black and Tans to brutalize the Palestinian Arab population, what in the fuck are you talking about?
This is a gross distortion. Some ex-RIC joined the Palestine Police after the disbandment of the RIC which was as far back as 1922 - about 700 joined the Palestine Gendarmerie - which in itself was disbanded in 1926 - and then perhaps no more than 200 remained in the 2 reconstituted forces that policed Transjordan and Palestine - some of which indeed remained throughout the Arab Revolt. They were certainly not "deployed....to brutalize the Palestinian Arab population" and indeed a large majority of the Palestinian police members after 1926, where in fact Muslim Palestinians. The deeply violent massacre and expulsion of the Jews of Hebron in the 1929 'riots' (a mixture of indigenous & newly settled Jews were targeted) and the inaction of the Palestinian police in stopping it (in some cases, the police took part), led to a reconstitution of the police forces thereafter. The Arab Revolt - and more violent anti-Arab (and anti Jewish) police actions only escalated after 1936. B &T involvement would have been marginal.
and FWIW...the self-styled 'anti-imperialist' Irgun split from regular Jewish resistance forces in attacking British targets. In doing this, they very publicly copied (and admired) IRA tactics to attack British military targets until 1948. These escalated during and after ww2 and indeed the most high profile attacks (inc. the assassination of the staunch Unionist Lord Moyne / bombing of British Army HQ by Irgun irregulars).
Overall, it's fair to say that the British military echelons - and rank & file - were split in their opinions of the Jews & Arabs. British did actively supply the Jordanian and Egyptian states in waiting with training and weaponry - and were far less inclined to do so regarding Jewish nationalist aspirations.
Not even mentioning that the British didn’t act to protect the Jews when they were killed by Arabs in Hebron, and the fact of White Paper invented literally to satisfy the Arabs (and they were satisfied.)
Indeed, taking a step back, the Palestinian police forces first and foremost served the British administration of the League of Nations Mandate - not a permanent British colonial mandate. Any ex-RIC participation would have been largely motivated by career considerations, rather than some form of sadistic ideology, let alone 'anti-Arab' considerations, which of course would have been counterintuitive to the prevailing anti-Ottoman / pro-British political winds that relied on Arab nationalist support. Indeed, modern Arab nationalism was arguably fostered by British political and colonial powers to counter Ottoman, Russian and other imperial forces - even French aspirations. The issue of Jewish national independence obviously played an adjacent role in the post WW1 landscape.
Comments like JayBug's simply reflect an 'anti-British / anti-imperialist' prism of the conflict that somehow needs to always tie into the Irish (nationalist) experience and appoint binary adversaries and roles. No nuance and certainly no consideration for the on the ground complexities and sensibilities play a role therein - so yes, it is informed by a sense of bigotry and anti-Jewish sentiment - manifesting as an unwillingness to ascribe national value to the Jewish indigenous experience (even if a minority in a minor Ottoman outpost) and the moral and legal legitimacy of first & second aliyah Jewish settlement - which did not displace Arab populations or rights.
An explicit policy to create a “national home for the Jewish people” is "siding with the Arabs"? The Arabs certainly didn't feel that way in 1947, and nor does anyone who is familiar with the history of the region, and certainly not Israeli historian's such as Benny Morris.
He's referring to the White Paper of 1939, conceived by the British to restrict Jewish national aspirations (and immigration) and to facilitate a bi-national state in which Jews would be a minority (and all that that entailed for their future rights - see Iraq, Egypt et al), rather than 2 separate states. It was overwhelmingly skewed to Arab national interests. It also represented a significant official shift away from the Balfour declaration. It found favour with mainstream Arab movements, yes.
Yes correct. This was also done concurrently with the Holocaust, essentially creating a reality in which the Jews had absolutely no place in the world to find refuge from Nazism on the scale that was needed to save European Jewry.
Excellent piece
Excellent piece. Tremendously thoughtful, educated commentary by a young, passionate individual. Many thanks.
Thank you for confronting Pappé. The pushback against this fraudster is far too absent. His "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" is a work of stunning academic malpractice... fake footnotes, 1948 Arab-invasion denial, antisemitic terminology ("cabal"), and worse. For those who don't know what to think, this video is a must-see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1_dc2wuteg
An Israeli acquaintance of mine told me many years ago that Pappe' was known in Israel as a complete charlatan, even amongst radical Israelis. The fact that he has become the spokesperson for European 'Anti Zionists" is a complete insult to the Israeli educational and political body. It would be the equivalent of selecting Karl Marx as the spokesperson for German society today. Yes Marx was German, but he also wanted to destroy Germany.
Are you able to provide a detailed list of every citation that you state is fake? I've read the book, and to be honest it's historiography is broadly centred along the same lines as that put forward by the other New Historians. The difference is the moral axiom that he takes in setting out to show that the creation of Israel was a strategic act of ethnic cleansing. I don't think the evidence gets us to that, but no one can deny that significant atrocities were committed which in turn drove depopulation of Arab settlements.
I recommend watching the video. It identifies endnotes that have no relevance to the text but are merely decorative.
Also, many of Pappé's endnotes simply state a volume/page number - no content - from a Hebrew-language resource that is unavailable to the public. These are the "newly declassified documents" on which his very thesis of ethnic cleansing depends. His thesis is that the five-country Arab invasion of day-old Israel was not the key point in 1948 but rather a minor, irrelevant, even doubtful event. Per Pappé, the true cause of anything that went wrong for Palestinians was malevolent backroom plotting by a Jewish cabal led by Ben-Gurion.
It's interesting, given how critical such documentation is to this new (and frankly, trope-laden thesis) that readers are fully satisfied with Pappé's opaque documentation style.
So I would like a detailed list of Pappé's Hebrew resource citations and their content. Also: per AI calculations, a disproportionately large number of Pappé's scholarly citations in "Ethnic Cleansing" are from his own works (see updated video link beneath recommended video).
You state , "no one can deny that significant atrocities were committed which in turn drove depopulation of Arab settlements," this is false. That there were "significant atrocities" and that alleged atrocities are what drove off Palestinians are by no means assertions accepted by all, including by all Arab scholars and witnesses. And, even if so, "consensus equals truth" is a reasoning fallacy.
Lastly, Jews are tired of playing defense against every fantastical demonization, even ones couched as "scholarship." Time for the accusers to provide a detailed explanation of why they killed their grandmother.
This is the same tactic Holocaust deniers are using. I often find myself going to the "go fuck yourself" response when I start getting asked to disprove lies.
It took 6 to get you out!
Well. Done. Lad.
Easily worth 6 men in a fight.
That's the form.
& I completely missed this last week:
"Just last week, while arguing that Ireland was not antisemitic, prominent radio host Pat Kenny put it to Dominic Green (a writer for ‘the Telegraph’ among other publications) that “Netanyahu orders the IDF to go into Gaza and kill babies”."
Good. Grief.
Keep it up there Young O'Mahony :D
I'm a bit surprised at Pat Kenny tbh.
Best read of the week. Thank you.
During the 2008-2009 academic year, I completed my Master's of Science (Development Studies) at UCD. The department head would not call Israel, Israel, but instead consistently, confidently, and arrogantly referred to it as Palestine. Again, this was in 2008-2009! The anti-semitism running through the Irish universities has been institutionalized for some time. As a Jew, I did not say anything because I was 23 years old at the time. I was confused and felt ashamed to be Jewish, as everyone else in the room just acted like this was normal.
I didn't know this. It's appalling.
Im sorry you endured that. Especially at such a precious time in your life. Stay strong...and proud.
😆😆😆. Proud Jew here living a successful, happy beautiful life. Sorry you cannot say the same. farewell miserable troll 👹
Thoroughly good and very insightful. As a Spaniard takinh the same stance, though less public, I can testify to how hard it is to see old friends turn on you simply for defending life while they pretend to hold the moral wand by defending terrorists. As a teacher, I am thoroughly ashamed of the profession, steadily working for the spread of Anti-Semitism, and as for my friends in acad6, they have preferred to continue with their utterly fake stance and have severed ties with me after the Bondi attacks. I kept on warning a highly positioned friend of many years at a University in Melbourne, that silence was the same as acquiescence but the attack did not change their set in stone mind.
It is all terribly sad.
Dietrich Bon Hoeffer said "Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless.Not to speak is to speak.Not to act is to act." He paid the ultimate price for opposing Nazism in Germany
I agree. The longer the silence, the deeper the wound. Not because I will miss what I thought they were, as friends were not, but because of what it means where it really matters: every day life for Jewish people every where, every day.
Thank you for standing for justice. Unfortunately, this is a very difficult position in Ireland these days.
I saw this car crash starting to happen, which is why I left Ireland twenty years ago. It is mainly the doing of the Ireland Palestine Solidarity Campaign, although they were obviously pushing at an open door.
Excellent piece. A future to hopefully avoid for other Western countries.
Thank you Jamie, please keep writing!
It seems to me that what you are describing is not a disagreement over policy but a collision with a closed moral economy.
Israel creates a particular problem for Irish political culture because it combines elements that Ireland’s moral self-image refuses to digest: a people with a genuine history of persecution who achieved sovereignty, exercise military power, and refuse to dissolve themselves to preserve moral innocence. Israel does not fit the role Ireland has assigned to “the victim.”
Irish nationalism is morally organised around resistance. The moment resistance succeeds, violence has to be re-mythologised or disowned. This is why IRA violence is frozen in a symbolic role: retroactively moralised, narrativised as tragic necessity, detached from its victims, and folded into national identity.
Israel, by contrast, exercises force as a sovereign state in real time, with consequences, trade-offs, and responsibility. There is no symbolic purification available. That difference strikes me as hugely significant.
The deeper structure is a binary Ireland depends on: victimhood is moral; power is immoral. Israel violates that binary by being a victim with power. The response is therefore not argument but inversion (Israel as uniquely evil), projection (genocide language), obsession (disproportionate focus), and moral certainty that no debate is required.
That is why what you describe sounds hysterical rather than argumentative. It is the sound of moral language failing to bind reality. Most people lose the ability to hear that after prolonged exposure. You haven’t yet, and that is precisely why the reaction still feels so stark.
You say Israel represents light and goodness. This doesn't fit with the vast destruction in Gaza. Not 'only' have Israel killed over 70,000 people in Gaza, they are allowing the violence, death and despair to spead into the West Bank where it seems Israelis can beat up or kill local people with impunity.
These are not the actions of a good or moral country. Not are they likely to build long term peace.
Allies killed more than 6 million Germans because in that war Allies represented light and goodness.
Israeli extremists end up in Israeli prisons which is the exact opposite of paying terrorists to slay Jews, as practiced by PA. Recently Israel made 276 arrests and 154 indictments.
People like this receive life sentences. Look up Amiram Ben‑Uliel, 15 Jewish terrorists serving life sentences, etc https://www.nytimes.com/1985/07/23/world/israeli-court-sentences-15-jewish-terrorists.html
Of course, you might be referring to Israel’s action against Hamas, Islamic Jihad, ISIS and other Jew-murdering genocidal terrorist entities based in the West Bank. That is indeed done “with impunity”. IDF had an absolute moral obligation to defend Israeli citizens. October 7th failure taught them a valuable lesson.
I can't believe you have had to go back 40 years for your reference to Israeli justice.
I didn’t. You have basic reading comprehension problems which explains antizionism as well as love for fascist propaganda from RT.
Your linked article, which demonstrates Israeli justice, is dated 1985.
Antizionism is common because of the way Israel behaves to all the people who it comes into contact with.
I can’t believe you rely on Hamas propaganda for your version of “justice.”
What is your version of justice?
Hamas charter is explicitly genocidal. Their ideology is from the Muslim Brotherhood. Islam has a long and bloody history of imperialistic conquest, colonialism, enslavement of non-Muslims, and oppression. Radical Muslims fully embrace that as good and see jihad as their duty. The “ Hamas entity” (see how that phrase can go both ways?) isn’t an resistance group. They are vile, evil jihadists. If anything, Israel has gone too easy on them. Jihadists should be exterminated and given no quarter. They are a menace to humanity.
Or facilitated hundreds of trucks of aid - even while being accused of wtholding aid. That's absolutely not genocide
You're not looking at why that destruction, which is mainly of buildings, was necessary. And by the way, that's not genocide.
The genocide was on October 7th when Hamas deliberately targeted Israeli civilians - including children and babies. Targeting Palestinian terrosts (Hamas) is only a “genocide” to their supporters.
Read Andrew Fox, Jake Wallis Simons, Douglas Murray, Melanie Phillips, John Spencer, James Glancy, Bernard Henri-Levy, and more, who all have experience and knowledge on the ground. And read them for what they actually have to say, rather than under any kind of heading about them.
Gosh, what an exceptionally intelligent and well-argued riposte from someone who has clearly researched the situation very carefully and not yielded to any emotion.
As an evident “expert” in urban warfare, what precisely would you have done differently than the IDF, given Hamas’ extensive tunnel infrastructure and abuse of otherwise protected sites such as hospitals, university buildings, mosques and private residences.
Real experts, such as West Point’s John Spencer, and over a hundred top Western military officers who have gone to see and investigate for themselves, take a radically different position from your lounge chair pontificating. To them, there is much to learn from an army that has brought the civilian-combatant ratio to an historic low in unprecedentedly complex battlefield conditions.
As any impartial observer would conclude, the devastation wrought in Gaza is a direct consequence of the strategy Hamas adopted and the tactics it spent nearly 20 years putting in place - with, it seems, the complicity of certain U.N. entities.
So you may spare us your uninformed, performative moralizing. Regurgitating Hamas talking points no longer convince anyone but the most ideologically driven.
Israel needed to start building peace decades ago. Every major decision they've made in the last twenty or thirty years has made the long term situation worse. Israel hold all the power, and with that comes responsibility.
You do know that Israel is surrounded by nearly 400 million Arab Muslims across 22 Arab majority states - a fact that should put paid to the “settler-colonial” nonsense framing. Why is it for Israel to “start building peace” while you ascribe zero agency to any Arab country?
In fact, over the decades, it has been Israel, in cooperation with willing Arab counterparts, that has built peace through treaties with Egypt and Jordan and more recently the Abraham Accords which stands as a framework for greater regional integration.
Maybe you really mean only the Palestinians and not the Arab world at large. If so, you have, on the one hand, fallen for stale Soviet propaganda that reframed the Arab-Israeli conflict to an Israeli-Palestinian one and turned an Islamist supremacist narrative into a “national liberation” one. On the other, you conveniently ignore the multiple attempts by Israel at peace faced always with the rejectionist mentality of the Palestinians that sees not coexistence with Israel but its replacement by another Arab majority country in which minorities live at sufferance.
In Gaza, the Palestinians had an opportunity to show what type of state they could build and on October 7, the world found out. Either the PA or Hamas could have built something sustainable, instead Hamas ousted the PA and began cross-border attacks which led to both Israel and Egypt closing their respective borders. As we have now witnessed, that blockade of arms was anything but hermetic. But the bottom line is that the Palestinians chose their way forward
So, it would appear that you - like so many others - have things precisely backwards: it’s for the Palestinians to “start building peace”. Unless you are among the legion who imagine them to be without any agency (in the face of all evidence) and so fall back on both a “White savior” complex twinned with a racism of low expectations, that’s the only way forward. Having Israel continue to bargain against itself is no longer an option after October 7.
Until the Palestinians become serious about nation building and coexistence, their future will remain dim.
This is spot on. The Palestinians have started and lost numerous wars with Israel since 1949. The pattern in human history is that peoples who do that lose territory as a result. But western defenders of Palestines act as if they are some special case and shouldn’t be responsible for their actions. They aren’t.
Like leaving Gaza 20 years ago?
That worked well.
Pete, you should meet my friend Reality.
She has much to teach you.
Good or moral country? Ever ask yourself why, if Israel loves killing Palestinians, it doesn't kill the ones in its own prisons but instead sustains them well past their intel use? Why it gave ex-prisoner Sinwar life-saving cancer treatment so he could go on to implement Oct. 7? Or why the kibbutz victims had helped transport Gazans to hospitals and jobs and had peace magnets on their refrigerators? Ever ask yourself why Palestinian babies are featured in media day after day, ideally with genetic diseases passed off as starvation (later admitted - maybe - in fine print) but Russian baby casualties of Ukrainian militancy or any other war are not (do you seriously think such baby victims don't exist)? Ever ask yourself *anything* beyond The New York Times narrative? Your morality compass falls on the side that won't even protect is *own* people with bomb shelters, and hides militants and weapons under hospitals (fact)? And do you know how many of the "70,000" people killed in Gaza (Hamas's figure) were militants? Shouldn't you?
I have never said Hamas are/were anything but awful. Yes, they're worse than the IDF, but Israel has all the power and any civilised society should aim for a higher bar than just ‘not as bad as Hamas’.
70,000 dead in Gaza plus a thousand killed with impunity in the West Bank. Do you really accept that is the behaviour of a decent society?
*Decency* explained: Israel putting up with Hamas's rocket fire for years and years and only responding when they went full-barbaric. Also decent that although all war is horrible, casualties (whatever the true number is) would undoubtedly be higher if not for Israel's moral code of issuing warnings to civilians, doing targeted attacks, and having to deal with an enemy population that is martyr-minded and deliberately placed in harm's way. You know Hamas is worse than Israel, so it's Hamas you should be debating; and if you can't, you should weigh the reason equitably. Instead, it's always about "Jewish morality on trial," a 2000 year-old farce; as is the "all-powerful" business. Hamas was holding civilian hostages, it has the backing of nuke-loving Iran and cash-flush Qatar, not to mention Western love--that's a whole lot of power. This is my last comment. Good luck.
Israel putting up with Hamas? In truth:
Israel killed 275 Palestinians in 2021
Israel killed 170 Palestinians in 2022
Israel killed about 170 Palestinians before Oct 7th 2023.
This is not normal behaviour for a developed country. But my main criticism of Israel is it's behaviour over the last 30 years. So many decisions have been taken that just made the tension worse, with no attempt to move towards a permanent peace.
Of course Hamas are worse, but they're not the dominant force in the region. Only Israel can choose the direction.
Hamas is now rewarding 50,00 widows of slain Hamas terrorists from the war. Then at least 8,000 died of natural causes. This is all public knowledge. Do the math.
How many of these people were Hamas, Islamic Jihad or other terrorists or “civilians” who also participated in the atrocities of 10/7 and beyond starting a war theyncouldnt win. Or are they all children under the age of 11 as international media parroting Hamas lies would have you believe? Obviously you have.
Jews can’t “settle” their homeland hon. “Palestinian” Arabs have Jordanian and Egyptian DNA - that’s where they come from. Gaza was part of Egypt and the “West Bank” was Transjordan. Palestinian Arabs have no indigenous rights to greater Israel. They were offered their own state in 1948 - and violently refused because Arab supremacy would never allow non-Muslim Jewish dhimmis and their diaspora brethren self-determination. Boo hoo they lost. That neither Egypt nor Jordan want them back speaks to their decades of fomenting violence (Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and Black September Jordan 1970-71).
https://www.wired.com/story/23andme-genetics-palestine/
I didn’t realize “international law” established a “right” to invade, slaughter, rape and kindap your neighbors.
Good and moral countries take action against genocidal entities that preach and carry out death and martyrdom against their citizens.
Not a single death would have occurred except for Oct 7. The PA pays lifelong stipends to Palestinians who murder Jews, thus incentivizing terror.
One side continually preaches hatred and "river to the sea," kills gays and has zero Jews.
The other side has 25% of its population Muslim/Arab/christian/Druze/Beduin/Bahai with full rights.
Bethlehem went from 80% Christian to under 10% after the PA started ruling it, yet within Israel proper, the Christian population grows, the only such phenomenon in the entire ME.
There is zero equivalence except in the mind of antisemites.
I agree, there is zero equivalence.
74,000 dead Palestinians.
Parroting Hamas is not your best argument.
You might want to add some context.
Hamas started the war.
Hamas uses its citizens as human shields, increasing the deaths.
Hamas includes its fighters and natural deaths and Pals it killed in its numbers.
Hamas had the power to stop deaths at any point but refused.
We see you don't like facts, or truth, or morality.
That’s on you.
70,000? I thought it was 7 million. It took years to get an accurate casualty count in Iraq (as it does in all wars) so I’ll wait until the post-war analysis is done and not rely on propaganda from the Hamas Health Ministry.
Excellent piece. We live in a time of widespread delusion manifested by moral inversion. Vast numbers of people are (to use the phraseology of Solzhenitsyn) “living by lies”. I am not Jewish, but I am appalled by the lies being told about Israel and Jews in general. Equally disgusting is the praise being heaped on murderous Islamist groups and regimes. It takes a strong sense of self and morality to push back against this tide of hatred and bigotry. This young man is very brave and selfless. He deserves wider recognition and respect.
Do you have any answer to why Ireland has become so consumed by Jew hatred? The question applies to everywhere in the Western world.
My own answer is tentatively that it is a combination of leftists being downstream of Marxist antisemitism, Islamic antisemitism, the internationalist hatred of both towards the original and quintessential nation state arising out of covenant with the divine, and a demonic rage against God, truth and goodness.
For debate...
Sadly, it's nothing new. Ireland sent condolences on the death of Hitler.
Well de Valera did. Not sure this would have been supported by the majority at that time.
How many Irish spoke out and against this, wrote opinion pieces about it, etc.? Their silence was deafening
There was an uproar about it.
When I was a child we learned that the IRA was trained by PLO. I think Sinn Féin propagates that Palestinians and Irish still have a similar struggle...
Ireland may not be intrinsically antisemitic, but it certainly comes across that way when its loudest voices adopt such maliciously false beliefs about Israel.
What is clear to any impartial observer is that the holdover antisemitism from the days of the supremacy of the Catholic Church in Ireland combined with a deformed Leftism unable to this day to separate from Soviet propaganda creates the fertile ground for antisemitism’s vulgar and crude expression - your serial commentary to this article being a case in point.
I'm beginning to wonder if I had a more balanced education in Protestant schools, or if an Roinn Oideachas has changed it since the 1970s
The only documented crime is your ongoing one against the English language and your intentional confusion between reality and what your ideology requires you to believe. Many readers will feel sorry for you and the delusions it spawned.
I am struck hard by what you write and by your courage to write it. And I am also terrified that this is happening.